## Stick puzzle: Move 1 stick to make 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 sides

**Part I:** Move 1 stick in the **figure above** and make a new figure, again with 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 stick sides.

**Part II:** How many such new figures can you make?

**Recommended time:** 5 minutes.

*Try solving the puzzle. Especially the second part is fun.*

### A Bonus Puzzle

With the experience of solving the first mixed puzzle it should be easy for you to solve this variation.

#### Second stick puzzle

**Part I:** In the puzzle figure move 1 stick to make 5 closed shapes with 3 or 4 sides.

**Part II:** How many ways can you form the new solution figure?

### Comment

This is the first time we face a matchstick puzzle made up of regular shapes of different types—one triangle of 3 sides, two squares and one tilted closed shape of 4 sides that is called a rhombus.

If you make a closed shape using matchsticks of same length, all sides of the shape will be of equal length. **In geometry such a shape is called a regular shape.**

A matchstick triangle (which is an equilateral triangle) is a regular shape, whereas you can make two types of closed regular shapes with 4 matchsticks—a square and a rhombus with tilted sides.

Because of the different types of regular shapes as components, you can classify this puzzle as a *matchstick puzzle of mixed shapes.*

### Concepts needed to solve the mixed shape matchstick puzzle

#### Common stick properties

A common stick between two closed shapes,

- destroys two regular shapes
**if removed**, **reduces**the need for number of sticks to form the two shapes independently**by 1**.

#### Diagonals of a square and a rhombus

In a regular shape like a rhombus A in the puzzle figure shown below, you can place a stick as the shorter diagonal to divide the rhombus into two triangles, increasing the number of closed shapes by 1.

**Note:**

Geometrically it is true that the shorter diagonal divides a rhombus into two equilateral triangles. But you won't use any geometry or math concepts in solving matchstick puzzles, isn't it?

You'll just try out the possibility by actually placing a stick to connect two nearer corners of the tilted four-sided closed shape and check for yourself whether you have got two triangles as a result.

But you can't use a stick as the diagonal of a square because diagonal is always longer than any of its sides in a square.

#### Two triangles can form a rhombus but not a square

As you can place a stick as the shorter diagonal in a rhombus, effectively you can combine two triangles to form a rhombus, but not a square.

These concepts you can understand just by creating the shapes with sticks. You don't really need any geometry background.

We will now solve the puzzle *systematically* using *step-by-step reasoning.*

### Solving the puzzle: Move 1 stick to make 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 sides stick puzzle

#### Stage 1: Analysis of requirement: define precisely what is needed—Making initial conclusions

The puzzle figure below has 4 closed shapes as components and the target figure also would have 4 closed shapes.

So you can confidently make your **first conclusion,**

The stick to be moved must destroy exactly 1 regular shape.

Verify and understand why this is true.

As a result, you can follow up with your **second confirmed conclusion** easily,

No common stick can be moved in this case.

These two conclusions are easy to make, but don't help much to bring the solution within easy reach. Not many, only three common sticks, are removed from consideration.

#### Second stage analysis: Going into more details

You'll avoid rhombus A because moving any of its 3 eligible sticks would create two hanging sticks—a complexity. You are aiming for the simplest promising path to a solution at this time.

So you would consider moving 1 out of 2 eligible sticks from the closed shapes B, C or D. Such an action will create a single hanging stick that is not a side of any closed shape.

#### Stage 2: More precise requirement specification for the stick to be moved

After examining the three pairs of movable sticks in shapes B, C and D, you are in a position to make requirement of stick to be moved more precise,

Moving a non-common stick out of possible two from a shape should create

Then the stick that has been moved can immediately be used for creating a new shape.1 hanging stick that should already be a side of an INCOMPLETE shape with only one side missing.

This is a *precise requirement specification arrived at in two steps* and solution is just a simple step away.

#### Stage 3: Applying requirement specification on the physical problem puzzle figure

Now as you look at the puzzle figure with this precise knowledge, it takes just a few seconds to identify the stick 1 of square B as the stick to move.

#### Solution: Move 1 to make 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 sides stick puzzle

Move stick 1 of shape B to form a new shape E adjacent to shape A.

Shape B is destroyed and new shape E is created keeping the number of shapes unchanged to 4 as before.

The solution is shown below.

### Part II of the stick puzzle: Any more solutions?

Solving the second part of the puzzle is easier now because you have already specified the requirements that thre stick to be moved must have.

For convenience, it is shown again,

Moving a non-common stick out of possible two from a shape should create 1 hanging stick that should already be a side of an INCOMPLETE shape with only one side missing. Then the stick that has been moved can immediately be used for creating a new shape.

Does it help in finding any other solution immediately?

*No, it doesn't.*

But it helps to eliminate shape C from consideration.

*What about shape A that you had ignored in the beginning?*

Now as you look more closely at shape A, you could see in no time that moving the rightmost stick 2 in shape A would give you the second solution.

#### Second solution: Move 1 stick to make 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 sides stick puzzle

Move stick 2 of shape A and form a triangle using this stick and the two hanging sticks as the other two sides.

This second solution figure is shown below.

With this experience of increased knowledge you are now able to form a **generalized requirement specification for the stick to be moved,**

The stick to be moved must destroy only one shape with the rest of the hanging sticks (possibly with existing sticks of other shapes) forming an INCOMPLETE shape

with only one side missingso that the stick moved can be used in forming anew closed shape.

This process of *refining requirement specification step by step* should generally be a great help in solving even complex problems systematically.

Apart from stick 1 in solution 1, only the stick 2 in shape A satisfied this precise but general requirement specification of stick that is to be moved. The two other hanging sticks were conveniently positioned so that the stick 2 could form a new triangle destroying the existing rhombus.

These two are then the only two solutions possible.

**Mark that** for solution 1, the single hanging stick alone was not enough to form a new triangle. The second side of the triangle E was supplied by an existing stick of shape A.

### Solution to the bonus puzzle: Move 1 stick to make 5 closed shapes of 3 or 4 sides

The puzzle element is hidden in this puzzle in the puzzle definition itself.

To solve it, you must first *define the puzzle problem clearly by asking the critical question,*

How many closed shapes of 3 or 4 sides does the puzzle figure have?

The number of closed shapes to start with is not 5 as it seems to be. The two triangles joined together top right form another additional outer 4 sided closed shape of a rhombus.

So the number of closed shapes to start with is 6.

And you have to move one stick to reduce the number to 5.

The only possible solution is shown below.

To reduce number of shapes by 1 in a single stick move,

The stick that is to be moved must destroy two shapes and is placed in a new position to create a new shape. That means, it must be a COMMON STICK.

If you reason this way, you would be able to easily cancel the possibilities of moving stick 1 or stick 2 as ineligible moves and home in to the only possible stick to be moved as **stick 3.**

### End note

Solving a puzzle by step-by-step reasoning takes away the joy of discovery of the solution in whatever-possible-way-I-can-solve attempts. Isn't it?

That's why we strongly recommend that you should try to solve the puzzle all by yourself in your own way and then only go through the reason-based solution to appreciate best of both worlds,

A combination of intuitive and reason-based solution approach should produce a very satisfying overall experience, you know.

### Puzzles you may enjoy

#### Riddles

#### Mathematical puzzles

**Reverse cheque puzzle solution**

**Counting eggs puzzles based on Euclid's division lemma**

**Monkey and the coconuts puzzle with solutions**

**10 digit Conway number puzzle with solution**

**World's Hardest Easy Geometry Puzzle Solved with Techniques Explained Step by Step**

**Hard Algebra Puzzles Solved by Basic Exponent Concepts and Reasoning**

#### Logic analysis puzzles

**Method based solution to Einstein's logic analysis puzzle, whose fish**

**How to solve Einstein's puzzle whose fish confidently, improved method based solution**

**Logic puzzle, When is Cheryl's birthday**

#### River crossing puzzles

**Farmer with fox, goose and bag of corn crossing the river puzzle**

**Two pigs and two hens crossing river puzzle**

*3 monkeys and 3 humans crossing river puzzle*

**King queen minister washerman river crossing puzzle**

#### Ball weighing puzzles

**Find the heavier among 8 identical balls in 2 weighing puzzle**

**Find the fake ball among 8 identical balls in 3 weighing puzzle**

**Find the fake ball among 9 identical balls in 3 weighing puzzle**

#### Matchstick puzzles

**Solution to 6 triangles to 5 triangles in 2 moves, first matchstick puzzle**

**Matchstick puzzle 5 squares to 4 squares in 2 moves**

**Matchstick puzzle 5 squares to 4 squares in 3 moves**

**Matchstick puzzle, Turn around the fish in 3 moves**

**Fifth Matchstick puzzle, Move 3 sticks in tic-tac-toe figure to form 3 perfect squares**

**Hexagonal wheel to 3 triangles by removing 4 sticks**

**Convert 5 squares to 4 squares in 3 stick moves, third 5 square matchstick puzzle**

**Matchstick Puzzle - Make the kite nose-dive in 5 stick moves**

**Make 5 squares from 6 in 2 stick moves - 6 square matchstick puzzle**

**Move 3 sticks and convert 5 squares to 4 squares in 4th 5 square matchstick puzzle**

**Move 3 sticks and convert 4 squares to 3 squares matchstick puzzle**

**Move 8 sticks and convert 5 squares to 2 squares matchstick puzzle**

**First Move 3 sticks and make 2 squares matchstick puzzle**

**Second Move 3 sticks and make 2 squares matchstick puzzle**

**Remove 3 matchsticks to leave 6 triangles puzzle**

**Add 3 matchsticks to make 4 triangles - lateral thinking stick puzzle**

**Move 1 stick to make 4 closed shapes each with 3 or 4 sides**

**Move 2 sticks to make 5 closed shapes matchstick puzzle**